09 Jul

One of my  friends in high school was Robin Ridington, now Professor Emeritus of Anthropology, University of British Columbia. He and Jillian Ridington do research with the Dane-zaa tribe of northern B.C. [1.] Robin was a school brain, high marks in everything, editor of the school paper and curious. He invited me to his home one day where we stuck our heads in a mammoth bass reflex speaker to hear a recording by E. Power Biggs on an organ with 32′ bass stops. We read instructions on rappelling and drove around Carroll County, Maryland in a giant Buick station wagon owned by his father, looking for cliffs high enough to test our book learning. Then Robin suggested we  join the  National Speleological Society. He wanted to attend a meeting of its Baltimore “Grotto” or chapter – he was never a half way guy, but I wanted to find a cave.

We purchased rope, carbide lamps, carbide pellets, helmets, overalls and boots, the basic accutrements for caving. All this stuff was stored in the back of  the station wagon. I can remember the caves we explored, I just can’t remember the order in which we explored them.  We referenced  Virginia and West Virginia state geological surveys which gave detailed instructions on the location of wild, not commercial caves, along with interior maps.

I know we went to the entrance of School House Cave in West Virginia. School House is famous. To explore this cave, mountain climbing techniques and equipment are required. It’s a linear cave consisting of a series of pits hundreds of feet deep, each pit having perpendicular walls. These pits are separated by a few yards of managable ground near its top or roof. That’s why Robin and I went no further than the entrance. To this day I can recall the feeling of unease I experienced as I approached the slope to the first drop into blackness. The most I can say is, “I was there.”

Another cave in West Virginia was called Licking Creek.  Robin and I drove in the mountains on narrow dirt roads, moving ever deeper into the forests, but according to the geological survey, ever closer to the caves location. A small cottage appeared. We stopped to ask for directions. I knocked on the front door and was greeted by a woman who looked to be in her 40s.  I asked, “do you know where Lickin Crick Cave is?”. She looked at me for a moment and said, “do you mean Licking Creek Cave?”     I was thoroughly humiliated by my attempt to speak what I had assumed to be Appalachian English. “Yes”, I said. She gave me directions. The cave entrance was nearby in the corner of a hardscrabble farm.

Our scariest adventure was Hedricks cave in West Virginia which was known to connect with Organ cave that was open to the public on a commercial basis.  We went on for hours and hours expecting to come out to a lighted commercial cave but finally realized that wasn’t going to happen.  Robin dropped a boulder on his foot.  We were almost stuck in a crevice passage and behind us leading back to the Hedricks entrance was a brutal long low room that had to be negotiated at a crawl or worse.  Robin had a moment of meltdown but finally we made our way back to the entrance, where a light snow was falling.  We ended that long day in a motel with Robin’s foot red and swollen.[2.]

Then, there was the cave in Harper’s Ferry, West Virginia. I think it was called George Washington Cave. Robin and I asked our girlfriends to  accompany us and during the drive we amused ourselves by reading aloud the rhymes on Burma Shave signs.[3.] Arriving at mid-day we found ourselves to be alone in a virtual ruin. My wife and I cannot remember any of the domestic dwellings visible in the photo below, including the church. Though mysteriously quiet and completely deserted, someone had been at work boarding up doors and windows. Famous in American history yet seemingly uncared for, Harper’s Ferry was then a site for ghosts.

Harper's Ferry, West Virginaia today. The Armory and other Civilm War Military buildings are nearest the river on left.

Harper’s Ferry, West Virginaia today. The Armory and other Civil War Military buildings are nearest the river on left.

Prior to the war between the states, Harper’s Ferry, which occupies a militarily and commercially strategic point at the juncture of the Potomac and Shenandoah Rivers, had served as an United States military arsenal and armory. Kansas abolitionist John Brown aided by 19 men including freed slaves, captured the arsenal from a small and unprepared garrison of US Army soldiers. The Federal government sent Colonel Robert E. Lee and his chief of staff Lieutenant J.E.B. Stuart to recapture the arsenal.

The four of us slowly walked among the decaying structures and headed out along old, unused railroad tracks towards the cave we hoped to find. After a short walk its opening appeared above a weedy slope. The cave proved to be littered with trash and very small. A bit of a downer. How George Washington’s name became attached to this bit of granite and limestone was a mystery. [4.] However, having girlfriends with us made everything more exciting, new and full of prospects. This also happened to be the second date for me and my future wife. Later Robin took our photo as we posed in front of a boarded doorway.

Many years later my wife and I revisited Harper’s Ferry. We drove the narrow  wooded road from Antietam battlefield, the route Longstreet and his corps had taken from Harper’s Ferry to join Lee.  In 1957, Harper’s Ferry possessed a powerful allure. Its old weathered buildings made history palpable.

Now a large asphalt parking lot had been added and we had to await a shuttle bus to take us onto the site. The decrepid wooden buildings had been restored and newly painted. Now Harper’s Ferry was a too convenient tourist stop with clean toilets and a gift shop. We couldn’t locate ourselves on the map we’d been carrying in our heads for the last forty years. We never got around to George Washington Cave. We looked for, but were never sure we’d found the doorway where we posed for our photo many years before. Just as well. Our Harper’s Ferry had been comandeered by the National Park Service.

We dismissed this new reality and returned to our original more romantic version. It remains in our minds to this day.

Harper's Ferry, 1957. Photo reconstruction by Lorraine Hickling Dillard, 2012.

Harper’s Ferry, 1957. Photo reconstruction by Lorraine Hickling Dillard, 2012.

[1.] Three interesting books by Robin and Jillian recount their research and experiences with native people.

Trail to Heaven: Knowledge and Narrative in the Northern Native Community, Robin Ridington, Douglas McIntyre, Toronto and Vancouver, 1988.

When You Sing it Now, Just Like New: First Nations Poetics, Voices and Representations, Robin Ridington and Jillian Ridington, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln and London, 2006.

Where Happiness Dwells: A History of the Dane-zaa First Nations.  Robin and Jillian Ridington. UBC Press: Vancouver.  2013.

[2.]  Robin Ridington wrote this paragraph on Organ/Hedricks Cave . Both he and Jillian enlarged and clarified other details in this article. My thanks to them both.

[3.] Burma Shave road side ads were a popular form of amusement for automobile travelers from 1927 until 1963. The signs generated huge sales and became a fixture of American life. Each line of a rhyme was posted on its own sign, spaced to facilitate reading at speed. Here’s one from 1955:

His crop – of whiskers – Needed reaping – That’s what kept – His Lena leaping

[4.] US Army  Captain Washington and a civilian named Washington were among John Brown’s hostages in Harper’s Ferry. I’ve yet to discover a connection between the cave and either of these men. (R.E.)

Harper's Ferry during the Civil War.  Without  the army tents, it appears as my friends and I found it in 1957.

Harper’s Ferry during the Civil War. Without the army tents, it appears as my friends and I found it in 1957.

Scan 2Scan 5Scan 1


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


  1. Fall Creek Marimbas

    July 10, 2013 at 11:24 am

    Hi Robin, Strange, I was just revisiting the book you suggested on Antietam. I read it earlier and started it again. Had my 6 month CT scan last week. All clear. Had left eye cataract surgery about 2weeks ago and the right eye next monday. Muckdogs are 10-11—eh…. R. A. Dickey is having problems. We had maybe the heaviest rain I have ever experienced Monday evening. Floods. I hear you had floods also. I LOVE, LOVE that photo of you and the magic woman. Love to both, Bill

  2. Gary Rockwell gmail

    July 10, 2013 at 3:43 pm

    Cool Robin. Been there many times and played at Don Ranelli’s Funeral next to the park a few years ago. Have biked passed there many times as well. It is still a haunting place to me as so much activity took place there in the terrible times in an incredibly beautiful setting where the Potomac gains strength. I enjoy your writing and have so much respect for your outlook on life and living! I still see you with the boyish face coming down Buffalo street with your grocery cart/laundry basket with a beret on for my first lesson from an Ithaca College student when I was in Junior H.S. Love to you and Elanor!!!!! g

  3. Dave Smith

    July 17, 2013 at 4:25 pm

    What a great, great picture of the two of you. I may have it framed! I never could have gone “caving” as you did, although Becky and I have gone skydiving. Hope to see you soon…

    Dave Smith (the younger)

  4. Ralph James

    April 17, 2017 at 6:47 pm

    I used to go caving in Jefferson County, WV in the 60’s. There is an easy cave that still appears on the USGS Charles Town (2) Quad sheet (
    It’s just west of the very NW end of Harper’s Ferry, right next to the railroad tracks. It’s labeled John Brown’s Cave. Unfortunately, the railroad blocked the entrance years ago. Moler’s Cave, not far away is also an easy cave, but clowns dumping spent carbide outside the entrance poisoned the owner’s cows, so he closed it. Nothing stays the same. 😦


Leave a Reply to Gary Rockwell gmail Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: